• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Sidebar
IU

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Menu

ScIUConversations in Science at Indiana University

  • Home
  • Home
  • About ScIU
  • Write with Us!
  • Contact ScIU
  • The Writers and Editors of ScIU
  • ScIU in the Classroom
  • Annual Science Communication Symposium
  • Search

Red wolves are endangered, but how can we protect a species we can’t define?

Posted on January 1, 2022 by Allison Nelson

Red wolves and grey wolves may have once been a single species. But throughout the 1900s, the interbreeding of coyotes and red wolves  blurred the line between species. How can we  determine whether red and grey wolves are the same or separate species?

The question is a pressing one, if you consider that conservation efforts are based on species.  In 1973, the Endangered Species Act was passed, creating the Endangered Species List, which mandates conservation efforts for every animal and plant on the list – based on species. Without a clear definition, conservationists don’t know what exactly they are trying to protect. The red wolf is on the list, but the more populous grey wolf is not. However, if the red wolf and grey wolf were considered the same species, the red wolf would be removed from the Endangered Species List and lose the protections and monetary assistance that the status of being listed provides.

First, a definition: a species is the fundamental biological grouping and denotes a group of the same organism that live, eat, and breed together. Species split frequently, whether through geographic separation, different populations beginning to eat different things, or hybridization (when one species mates with another) (Sites and Marshall, 2004). Hybridization blurs the species boundary. The dog and wolf in the photos below are difficult to tell apart just based on their faces and skulls. Sometimes, a face or skull is all we have.

Two pictures side by side of similar looking animals. On the left is a Siberian husky laying on its stomach in the grass and staring at the camera. On the right is a Czechoslovakian wolfdog (hybrid) looking off camera, its chest is partially visible, and the background is blurred foliage.
Can you tell which picture is a dog and which is a wolf-dog hybrid? On the left is a Siberian husky laying on its stomach in the grass and staring at the camera. On the right is a Czechoslovakian wolfdog (hybrid) looking off camera, its chest is partially visible, and the background is blurred foliage. Both animals have similar face shapes, and it is not readily apparent which one is a dog and which one is a dog-wolf hybrid.

Species definitions are nonetheless  important for conservation efforts. 

Fortunately, a more sophisticated version of the above skull-shape comparison can help define species by looking at quantifiable differences between skulls. This process is called geometric morphometrics. The shape of the cheekbone, or the curve of the top of the skull are some examples of the shapes that can be analyzed. These shapes are taken from 2D pictures, then plotted onto a graphCartesian coordinates. With many skulls, trends of each shape can be seen on this graph. If the shape of the cheekbone looks one way in grey wolves, a second way in red wolves, a third way in coyotes, and the red wolf-coyote hybrids look a fourth way, then these species are separate.

Dog skull facing left on a green background. The bottom edge of the jaw and top of the back of the skull are outlined.
This is an example of some of the skull shape curves that are assessed with geometric morphometrics, shown on a dog skull.

Maybe the species distinctions will be completely different from what we expect. There might not be a difference in the shapes, which in itself would be interesting. Or maybe the shapes will be a confusing blob, and a different method will be needed to figure out what is going on. Although genetics are complicated by the inbreeding, difficult with the inbreeding, they may be able to shed some light on differences between the groups.

There’s a question of whether the original wolves in North America were red wolves. This is a complicated question since red wolves interbred heavily with coyotes as their geographic range shrank. They used to live across the southeastern United States but have been reduced to a small region of North Carolina and the Louisiana-Texas border. Red wolves were declared extinct in the wild in 1980, when conservation efforts led to their being rounded up and moved  to a recovery area in North Carolina. They typically wear radio collars for tracking purposes. (Hinton, et al., 2013)

Luckily, there are skulls from red wolves before the interbreeding with the coyotes became routine, so geometric morphometrics can be done on red wolves, grey wolves, coyotes, and red wolf-coyote hybrids in the hope of defining each animal and figuring out if they are in danger of extinction.  Clarifying the distinctions between the four groups will solidify the species boundaries that inform conservation efforts. If all red wolves have a particular curve on their skulls that is not seen on (or is more pronounced than) any other skulls, that would be evidence that they are a separate group. Likewise, if grey wolves have a different curve that is distinct from what is seen on all of the non-grey wolf skulls, then grey wolves are a distinct group. If those differences are statistically significant, it is evidence that those groups are separate species. Knowing what (and how many) animals are in each species allows determination of extinction risk.

Conservation is a difficult field. There’s lots of contention among scientists about species definitions, best practices for helping different animals (as well as plants), and a general lack of funding. With constant advancements in science, conservation is always changing. As seen with the wolves, species definitions are also a source of headaches with much room for debate. Yet, most scientists want what is best for the animal to the best of our knowledge at that moment. And as that knowledge changes, our response will too.

Acknowledgements:

EAS-G 590 has allowed me to explore my thesis topic and amass background knowledge. Writing the first draft of this post was part of this class, as a part of practicing writing for different audiences.

References:

Hinton, Joseph W., Michael J. Chamberlain, and David R. Rabon. “Red wolf (Canis rufus) recovery: a review with suggestions for future research.” Animals 3.3 (2013): 722-744.

Sites Jr, Jack W., and Jonathon C. Marshall. “Operational criteria for delimiting species.” Annu. Rev. Ecol. Evol. Syst. 35 (2004): 199-227.

Edited by Evan Arnet and Liz Rosdeitcher

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related

Filed under: Cutting-Edge Science at IUTagged Biology, canids, conservation, Endangered Species Act, grey wolves, North America, paleontology, red wolves, wolves

12 Comments

  1. sportstototvcom July 16th, 2022

    What?s up, just wanted to mention, I loved this post. It was practical.
    Keep on posting!

    Reply
  2. sportstotohot.com July 29th, 2022

    Pretty! This has been an incredibly wonderful article. Thank you for supplying this information.

    Reply
  3. casinositenet.com July 29th, 2022

    Very nice article. I absolutely love this website. Thanks!

    Reply
  4. casinositezone.com July 31st, 2022

    Thank you for providing a good quality article.

    Reply
  5. casinositehot.com August 12th, 2022

    This is such an outstanding article; I have appreciated the fact that you took take some good time to work on this very blog.

    Reply
  6. sportstotolink.com August 12th, 2022

    This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives indepth information. Thanks for this nice article.

    Reply
  7. sportstoto365 August 23rd, 2022

    Keep posting such compelling post, for your visitors we are just in love with your content.

    Reply
  8. totopickpro August 25th, 2022

    You made some really good points there. Good job.

    Reply
  9. sportstoto link August 25th, 2022

    Great blog article. Really looking forward to read more.
    Oh well, I came across your blog site and I found this stunning and interesting to read

    Reply
  10. aaiko0655 August 30th, 2022

    Excellent information on your blog, thank you for taking the time to share with us. Amazing insight you have on this, it’s nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists.

    Reply
  11. aiya67484 August 30th, 2022

    SO good indeed! Glad to have found your page!! This is such great work!! Interesting to read for sure!!

    Reply
  12. baccaratsitetop September 14th, 2022

    Yes i am completely concurred with this article and i simply need say this article is extremely decent and exceptionally useful article.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Additional Content

Search ScIU

Categories

Tag cloud

#Education #scicomm animal behavior anthropology astronomy astrophysics Biology biotechnology Black History Month brain cannabinoids Chemistry climate change conservation coronavirus COVID–19 diversity Diversity in Science diversity in STEM Ecology environment evolution geology history and philosophy of science infectious disease Interdisciplinary Interview Mental Health methods microbiology neuroscience outreach physics Plants primates psychology Research science science communication science education Science Outreach science policy Statistics STEM women in STEM

Subscribe

Receive a weekly email with our new content! We will not share or use your information for any other purposes, and you may opt out at any time.

Please, insert a valid email.

Thank you, your email will be added to the mailing list once you click on the link in the confirmation email.

Spam protection has stopped this request. Please contact site owner for help.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Current Contributors

  • Log in
  • SPLAT
  • ScIU Guides

Indiana University

Copyright © 2022 The Trustees of Indiana University | Privacy Notice | Accessibility Help

  • Home
  • About ScIU
  • Write with Us!
  • Contact ScIU
  • The Writers and Editors of ScIU
  • ScIU in the Classroom
  • Annual Science Communication Symposium
College of Arts + Sciences

Are you a graduate student at IUB? Would you like to write for ScIU? Email sciucomm@iu.edu


Subscribe

Subscribe By Email

Get every new post delivered right to your inbox.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

 

Loading Comments...