• Skip to Content
  • Skip to Sidebar
IU

Indiana University Bloomington Indiana University Bloomington IU Bloomington

Menu

ScIUConversations in Science at Indiana University

  • Home
  • Home
  • About ScIU
  • Write with Us!
  • Contact ScIU
  • The Writers and Editors of ScIU
  • ScIU in the Classroom
  • Annual Science Communication Symposium
  • Search

Share our rejections

Posted on January 11, 2020 by Dan Myers

Cat cuddles on the couch.
My cat, Pumpkin, comforted me as I read my latest rejection letter.

My cat comforted me as I read my latest rejection letter: my manuscript had once again been denied by a scholarly journal. 

Rejection letters make us feel awful. Whether these letters are just a few lines of text, or printed with elaborate letterheads on sturdy paper, we always feel grief and disappointment. I argue that as scientists and academics we need to change this by broadly sharing our rejections as well as our victories. This would eliminate the stigmas surrounding rejection letters, making scientists happier and less discouraged when they get them. 

I’ll start. I have one academic publication and seven rejection letters from scientific journals. One of my manuscripts alone has been rejected by three journals. When applying to PhD programs, I was accepted by two and rejected by two. I’ve received rejection letters from several grants and scholarship applications as well. I’ve learned that in academia, if you want something, you have to apply for it several times.

So why did I feel so bummed when I read this latest rejection letter? “How could this be?” I asked my cuddly calico cat, Pumpkin. I then felt embarrassed while writing the email to my co-authors, notifying them of the rejection. People were going to ask about the manuscript and I just felt awkward. 

Photo of rejection letter.
Rejection letters are usually written nicely and help us make valuable improvements, but still make me bummed.

What I felt was wrong. These letters shouldn’t bring us down. The truth is that rejection letters are the norm in any academic or scientific application. Everyone has a pile of them, especially the most famous scientists. Rejections occur because we boldly applied for something too ambitious. The lessons we learn from them are the building blocks we use to achieve these high ambitions: publishing our papers, securing our fellowships, and presenting our research. Rejection letters are a normal and essential part of academic life.

Rejection letter with elaborate letterhead.
Some rejection letters have official letterhead.

We have created a stigma about rejections by only sharing victories on our CVs, websites, and social media. This has skewed perceptions so that rejection letters seem like a big misfortune. This discouragement is a real problem and I’m sure that some aspiring scientists just give up because of it.

To solve this problem, we need to broadly share our rejections, not just our victories. We need to list rejections on our websites, post them to social media, and tell our lab mates and students. We need to add a “Rejections” section to our CVs and watch as they grow 3x as long. By eliminating the stigma surrounding rejection letters, they will be less of a problem. Scientists will be happier and less discouraged, and our fellow academics won’t have to spend a lonely evening trying to justify their rejection to their cat.

Would you like to tally up your rejections in this post’s comments?

Acknowledgements:

I would like to thank Sandra Sanchez for the idea for this post.

Edited by Lana Ruck and Evan Arnet

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Related

Filed under: General ScienceTagged academics, letter, publishing, Rejection, science

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Additional Content

Search ScIU

Categories

Tag cloud

#Education #scicomm animal behavior anthropology archaeology astronomy astrophysics Biology biotechnology Black History Month brain cannabinoids cannabis Chemistry climate change conservation coronavirus COVID–19 Diversity in Science diversity in STEM Ecology environment evolution geology history and philosophy of science infectious disease Interdisciplinary Interview Mental Health methods microbiology neuroscience outreach physics Plants primates psychology Research science communication science education Science Outreach science policy Statistics STEM women in STEM

Subscribe

Receive a weekly email with our new content! We will not share or use your information for any other purposes, and you may opt out at any time.

Please, insert a valid email.

Thank you, your email will be added to the mailing list once you click on the link in the confirmation email.

Spam protection has stopped this request. Please contact site owner for help.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Current Contributors

  • Log in
  • SPLAT
  • ScIU Guides

Indiana University

Copyright © 2022 The Trustees of Indiana University | Privacy Notice | Accessibility Help

  • Home
  • About ScIU
  • Write with Us!
  • Contact ScIU
  • The Writers and Editors of ScIU
  • ScIU in the Classroom
  • Annual Science Communication Symposium
College of Arts + Sciences

Are you a graduate student at IUB? Would you like to write for ScIU? Email sciucomm@iu.edu


Subscribe

Subscribe By Email

Get every new post delivered right to your inbox.

This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

 

Loading Comments...